Soaring commodity prices and faltering urban demand have made things anything but predictable for risk-averse investors who usually find comfort in defensive sectors like consumer staples. This unease is quite visible in the Nifty FMCG index, which has barely managed to stay afloat so far this year, up by less than a per cent. In contrast, the broader Nifty50 index has surged over 3.45% during the same period.